Skip to content
Konverrt

Blog · Guide

What cold email reply rate to expect from business owners

By Gio Bezhanishvili · November 20, 2026 · 6 min read
Ink illustration of a long row of cream envelopes on a dark desk, one envelope in blue

I was on a call with an advisor whose team was running cold email on their own. Their problem was they could not get past about a 1.5% reply rate.

They were also quite confused, because when they went on LinkedIn they saw people hitting 3%, 5%, and some were even flexing 10% or 15% reply rates. It really hurt their confidence.

So I want you to take all of that with a grain of salt. Most of what you see out there is noise, and it does not reflect the reality of outreach to business owners, on the sell side or the buy side.

Even though 1.5% is on the low end, I want to give you the numbers we are seeing from emailing thousands of owners across many different industries every month.

Know which reply rate it is

When I get on calls with a private equity firm or an M&A firm and they ask me, “What’s your reply rate?”, I tell them there’s a difference between three things: a reply to the email, an actual human reply, and someone who wants to talk.

Since late May, we emailed 16,548 owners on behalf of advisors. This is how it broke down:

Advisor emails, 16,548 ownersShare of owners
Replied3.8%
A real person replied1.8%
Wanted to talk1 in 280

So more than half of the replies were robots, like autoresponders or out-of-office messages. Out of 631 owners who replied, 338, or 54%, only sent an auto-reply.

And out of the real people who replied, about 1 in 5 were interested.

Let’s say you email 1,000 owners. About 38 reply, about 18 are real people, and about 3 or 4 want to talk with you.

Based on some of the research I’ve seen, Instantly currently says 3.43% and Hunter says 4.5%. As far as I know, they count every reply, robots included. Belkins puts the average at 0.45% of emails sent, and Sales.co, which counts only real people, also lands at about 0.45%.

Compare that with ours: 3.8% replied, but only 1.8% were real people and 0.36% were interested.

Most real replies aren’t a yes either. This is how 647 real replies broke down, advisor and buyer emails together:

647 real replies, both sidesShare
Interested28%
Not interested36%
Asked to be taken off the list13%
Reach out later7%
Wrong person or no longer there6%

The rest were mostly owners who pushed back with a question, referred us to someone else, or had retired.

The owners who want us to reach out later still go into our follow-up pipeline, because they’re still a good target.

Expect more when you name a buyer

There’s also a difference between a buyer pitch and an advisor pitch, and that is something that really determines how likely the owner is to give you a response.

By advisor, I mean the email does not mention any specific buyer. It just lets the owner know, “If you want to sell, I can help you. Let’s have a confidential conversation.”

When we named a specific buyer, we reached out to 12,684 owners and got 2.8% real replies, compared to 1.8% for an advisor. These were different clients, lists and months, so it’s not a clean head-to-head test.

On the buyer side, 1 in 95 wanted to talk, compared to 1 in 280 for an advisor. The difference is about 3x. And about 4 in 10 real replies were interested, compared to about 2 in 10 on the advisor side.

By the way, if you’re sell-side and you have a list of buyers you can mention, that works as well. You can improve your performance by naming a specific buyer, and you don’t even have to name them. You can describe them, so the owner feels that there’s actually someone there and you are not talking out of thin air.

If you don’t want to mention a buyer, you can create some sort of checklist, for example an exit preparation checklist, or a quick runbook. That’s a valuable resource someone can respond to and wants to receive. It qualifies them less for a sales conversation, but every reply from a qualified owner is a good reason to add that lead to the top of your funnel.

Know which industries write back

It’s also very important who is responding, because we run campaigns targeting different industries. These are real human reply rates on advisor emails:

Industry, advisor emailsOwners emailedReal repliesReal reply rate
Machine shops1,092343.1%
Construction1,205262.2%
Industrial machinery1,847392.1%
Plastics and chemicals58040.7%
Engineering58530.5%
IT and software50010.2%

Those are replies, not interested owners. The bottom rows have only a handful of replies each, so read them as a direction rather than an exact number.

Keep it to 2 or 3 emails

There’s one more thing I want to touch on. Firms who reach out to owners make their sequences way too long. They make 5- or 7-step follow-ups, like a never-ending sequence. Most of the time, all it does is annoy the prospect and get you marked as spam.

I’m not saying it cannot work for very niche and specific cases, but for the most part, this is what we see with our advisor emails:

Advisor emails, 296 real repliesShare of real replies
After email 152%
After email 242%
After email 3 or later6%

About half needed the follow-up, and almost nobody replied after the third email.

Owners also reply quite fast. Our median is under 1 hour after the email they answer, and about 9 in 10 reply within 24 hours of it. Only 7% reply more than 2 weeks after the first email.

So you should not waste your sending volume on the same leads. Instead, focus on finding more potential prospects in your industry, and target them with a 2-step or at most 3-step sequence.

Budget by owners, not replies

So how should you budget? Let’s say you want 10 conversations with owners. How many owners should you email in the first place, and what happens if your niche only has 2,000 owners?

As an advisor, based on our data, you need to reach about 2,800 owners for 10 owners who want to talk, because about 1 in 280 do.

When you can mention a buyer, you need about 950 owners, not even 1,000, because about 1 in 95 want to talk.

A 2,000-owner niche emailed once gives about 7 conversations for a sell-side advisor, and about 21 when you can name a buyer.

Keep growing that top of the funnel with every reply from a qualified owner, and you and your team can start working it. It’s way warmer and way more qualified than prospecting completely cold.

Run the test on your own list

At the end of the day, this is what I recommend:

  1. Get as specific as possible. If you can describe a buyer, or mention the buyer you potentially have someone for, it will get you good replies.
  2. Offer something useful if you can’t. An exit preparation checklist or a quick runbook is something owners want to receive.
  3. Change your scripts. Our post on what to say in a cold email to a business owner about selling will help you nail down what to say in the email.
  4. Do the A/B test. Run one version with your current script and one with the new script, and compare.

If you still see no difference, then I would say it’s a matter of the list you built. You need to change either the list or the infrastructure you have.

Questions people ask

What is a good cold email reply rate to business owners?

For an advisor, about 3.8% of owners reply, about 1.8% are a real person, and about 1 in 280 want to talk. When you name a specific buyer, about 2.8% reply as a real person and about 1 in 95 want to talk.

Why do people on LinkedIn show 10% or 15% reply rates?

Most of that is noise. A lot of reply rates count every reply, and more than half the replies to our advisor emails were auto-replies or out-of-office messages.

How many follow-ups should a cold email to business owners have?

Two steps, three at most. About 4 in 10 real replies to advisor emails came after the second email, and only 6% came after the third email or later.

How many owners do I need to email to get 10 conversations?

About 2,800 owners as an advisor, because about 1 in 280 want to talk. About 950 if you can name a buyer, because about 1 in 95 want to talk.

Sources

Apply for a pilot batch

Four questions, two minutes. We size your market before we quote, so the first reply you get from us is a number, not a pitch.

Apply for a pilot batch
Redacted reply · swipe to read